PHILIPSBURG:--- The Court of First Instance of St. Maarten has ordered RBC Royal Bank N.V. to continue providing banking services to money transfer company Union Caribe N.V. under its usual terms and without new restrictions. If RBC has already ended the relationship, it must restore it immediately. The November 6 ruling is enforceable even if either party appeals.
Union Caribe operates in St. Maarten, Aruba, and Curaçao and primarily handles international money transfers for individuals. The company told the court it would have to cease operations in St. Maarten if it lost access to its U.S. dollar account. It said other banks on the island were unwilling to take it on as a customer. The court found that Union Caribe had shown it needed the dollar account to operate and that the matter was urgent.
RBC gave notice in March
RBC notified Union Caribe on March 25 that it would terminate the St. Maarten banking relationship on July 25. Union Caribe’s lawyer asked for an explanation in June. The judgment records that RBC did not respond and that the accounts continued operating after the July deadline.
In an October 7 letter, RBC announced that U.S. dollar services would end on October 16 and that the remaining accounts would close by October 26. The bank said its U.S. correspondent bank had instructed it to stop processing the company's dollar transactions. Union Caribe learned of the letter on October 20, filed its urgent application two days later, and still had access to its dollar account when the case was heard on October 26.
Court questioned RBC’s reliance on the Aruba case
RBC cited its anti-money-laundering obligations and pointed to concerns it had raised in Aruba about cash flows, verification of the source of funds, and customer screening. The court found that RBC had failed to explain how those concerns applied to the St. Maarten operation, whose accounts were subject to a separate termination notice.
The court also found that the Wells Fargo instruction RBC relied on was addressed to RBC in Aruba and gave no reasons for the restriction. On the evidence before it, the court could not determine whether Wells Fargo would also refuse to process transactions for Union Caribe in St. Maarten. The order applies to both the U.S. dollar and local-currency accounts.
Judge G. Konings found that Union Caribe’s need to retain banking access outweighed RBC’s stated grounds for ending the relationship. The judge left the order without a fixed duration because circumstances could arise that would justify a future termination. Union Caribe also sought a daily penalty for noncompliance. The court declined to impose one after RBC said it would comply and ordered the bank to pay Cg. 3,000 in legal costs.