Court dismisses US$160,000 claim against RE/MAX in Cole Bay condo dispute.

Buyer paid the developer in full, but title was never transferred despite a 2023 court order.

remaxcourt17112026PHILIPSBURG:---  The Court of First Instance has dismissed a US$160,000 claim against RE/MAX Island Properties and a real estate agent brought by a buyer who paid in full for a condominium in Cole Bay but never received title. In its October 27 ruling, the court found that neither the brokerage nor the agent breached a duty of care by failing to warn the buyer about paying the developer directly.

Developer accepted a lower price on condition of prompt payment

The buyer signed a purchase agreement with Carbon Acquisition Group N.V. on July 22, 2020, for a unit in the Carbon Grove project. Carbon accepted his reduced offer of US$ 160,000 on the condition that he pay the full amount directly to the company by August 19, 2020. The buyer paid, but Carbon did not transfer title. In November 2023, the court ordered Carbon to transfer the property, threatening a penalty. The October 2026 judgment records that the transfer still had not taken place.

The buyer argued that the agent had guided him through the purchase and should have warned him not to send the money directly to Carbon without using a notary or an escrow account. The judge found that the WhatsApp messages showed the agent relaying Carbon’s payment condition and supplying bank details. The messages did not establish that she advised the buyer to accept the condition or helped set it.

Court finds no breach of duty

The court said a seller’s agent owes a duty of care to prospective buyers and that any obligation to warn depends on the circumstances. Both sides acknowledged at the hearing that direct payment to a seller without going through a notary was not unusual in St. Maarten. Several units in the project had already been completed, and messages raising concerns about Carbon’s finances came after the sale agreement. The court found that those messages did not show the agent knew, or could have known, of financial trouble when the deal was made.

RE/MAX argued that the agent had acted independently. The judge found that the buyer could reasonably assume she represented the brokerage. The unit was advertised on the RE/MAX website, the agent used a RE/MAX email address, and the purchase agreement named RE/MAX as the broker. The court nevertheless dismissed all claims against both defendants and ordered the buyer to pay Cg. 6,000 in legal costs to each, for a combined Cg. 12,000 in base costs.