Dear Editor;
As Co-Founder of the St. Peters Community Council, I have closely followed the court proceedings concerning the fatal shooting of the late Rudy Benjamin. The recent request by both the Public Prosecutor and the Defense to acquit the three officers involved has raised significant concerns within the St. Peters community regarding several aspects of the case.
Members of the community believe it is a cover-up with little transparency to protect the three officers, based on the Public Prosecutor's decision to acquit them. The question is why the Public Prosecutor brought the case to court if he had already decided to acquit the officers.
Important questions remain unanswered and warrant further examination before the Judge reaches a final decision. In particular, concerns have been raised regarding the written witness testimony, available evidence, and the interpretation of surveillance footage presented during the proceedings.
A key point of concern is the written statement of a witness who reportedly observed the incident, which was conveniently left out of the hearing. Community members believe that this statement should be carefully reviewed alongside all other available evidence to ensure a complete and impartial assessment of the facts.
The community is also calling for greater transparency regarding the available camera footage and other relevant evidence. Given the differing interpretations of the footage presented during the hearing, many residents believe the camera footage should be made public, and an independent analysis could help provide additional clarity and strengthen public confidence in the judicial process.
Questions have also been raised about the inconsistencies, suppressed evidence, and the officers contradicting themselves in their statements, the sequence of events immediately following the shooting, and the procedures followed at the scene and decisions made during the subsequent investigation.
Community members believe these matters deserve further clarification to address public concerns and reduce speculation. This unique court case sets a bad precedent for speaking the truth and rebuilding trust in the community.
The St. Peters community also notes that several witness accounts and statements may provide additional context about the circumstances leading up to the incident, rather than relying on one person the police conveniently interviewed that night to defend their case in Court. Mr. Benjamin spoke to several residents that night, even promising one a visit in the morning to clean her yard.
A comprehensive review of all available testimony would help the court better understand what occurred and reach an informed conclusion.
A SURPRISED APPROACH in an unmarked car that the officers took so close up, with no verbal command, will shock anyone, even an intoxicated person, leaving him with little time to react. Some residents ask if this is the new norm of the Flex Team: surprising, driving close up, and assassinating residents if the police presume they have a firearm.
I was there in court and saw the video. The late Rudy wasn't even paying attention when the officers drove up so close, and Rudy was surprised and put up one hand, trying to shout "don't shoot," and the other hand, trying to show it was not a real gun. In the video, Rudy never pointed the air gun at the officers, who already started shooting him instantly at close range. The officers really surprised him.
The Police Officers could have handled the situation differently by parking their unmarked vehicle a distance away, identifying themselves and still have coverage. While recognizing the difficult and often dangerous responsibilities carried out by law enforcement officers and the law says that a police officer has the right to shoot somebody if they feel threatened by an individual (which was not the case in this fatal shooting), community members believe every use-of-force incident should be subject to thorough scrutiny to ensure accountability, fairness, and adherence to established procedures. Public confidence in the justice system depends on a transparent process that considers all relevant evidence.
On behalf of many residents, I respectfully urge the Court to show the camera footage to the public, consider all available evidence, including witness statements and expert analysis where appropriate, before rendering a final decision. A comprehensive review of the case would help address lingering concerns and reinforce public trust in the administration of justice.
The St. Peters community remains committed to promoting constructive dialogue, accountability, and positive relations between residents and law enforcement.
The police department should also follow up with the resident whose car was shot up by the officers, and no one contacted the resident to compensate for the car.
We hope this matter is resolved in a way that brings clarity, fairness, and healing to all those affected, including the family of the late Rudy Benjamin, the officers involved, and the wider community.
Maurice Lake
Co-Founder of the St. Peters Community Council.







