Vinaora Nivo Slider 3.xVinaora Nivo Slider 3.xVinaora Nivo Slider 3.x
Vinaora Nivo Slider 3.xVinaora Nivo Slider 3.xVinaora Nivo Slider 3.x

St Maarten Court declines to hear US$898,789 Yacht collision claim despite local attachment.

boatclaim18112026PHILIPSBURG:---  The Court of First Instance of Sint Maarten has ruled that it lacks jurisdiction to hear a US$898,789.88 damages claim over a collision that sank a tugboat in Fort Lauderdale, Florida. The tugboat’s owner secured a prejudgment attachment of the charter yacht Grand Illusions in Sint Maarten, but the court found that the company could seek payment under security provided in the United States without a Sint Maarten judgment.

The collision occurred on November 26, 2025, and sank the tugboat Kimberley, owned by Florida-based Steel Marine Towing and Salvage LLC. On December 5, Steel Marine obtained a prejudgment attachment of the Grand Illusions in Sint Maarten. Fairview Group LLC, a California company, owns the yacht. Steel Marine filed its damages action on December 18.

Steel Marine alleged that a technical malfunction caused the yacht to surge forward at full power while its captain was away from the controls. The company sought to hold Fairview liable for repair costs and income it said it lost while the tugboat was out of service for 67 days. It also sought statutory interest and legal costs. Fairview disputed the claim.

Why the yacht’s attachment fell short

Under Sint Maarten’s ordinary jurisdiction rule, a defendant is generally sued where it is based. Steel Marine relied on an exception under Article 767 of Sint Maarten’s Code of Civil Procedure that can allow the court that authorized a prejudgment attachment to hear the underlying claim against a foreign defendant. The provision is designed to preserve the value of a local attachment when a claimant has no other way to obtain an enforceable judgment.

The court noted that Sint Maarten and the United States have no treaty governing the enforcement of civil judgments. In this case, however, Fairview arranged for a U.S.-based party to provide security under U.S. law after the yacht was attached. At the August 27 hearing, Steel Marine acknowledged that its ability to seek payment under that security did not depend on a decision from a Sint Maarten court. Judge G. Konings found that this removed the need to exercise jurisdiction under the attachment rule.

The judge also found that the underlying dispute had no close connection to Sint Maarten. The collision occurred in Florida, both vessels belonged to U.S. companies, and the parties agreed that U.S. federal maritime law and, in part, Florida law applied.

Fairview’s participation did not establish jurisdiction

Steel Marine also argued that Fairview had implicitly accepted the court’s jurisdiction by defending the claim without objecting in its first written response. Fairview challenged jurisdiction at the hearing. The court held that it had to examine its authority on its own initiative even if Fairview’s participation could be treated as implied consent. Given the dispute’s ties to the United States, the judge found no reasonable basis for hearing it in Sint Maarten.

The court left the question of who was responsible for the collision unresolved and ordered Steel Marine to pay Fairview Cg 10,000 in legal costs, plus statutory interest from the 14th day after formal service of the judgment until the costs are paid in full. The Court issued the judgment on October 13, 2026, and published it on November 18.


Vinaora Nivo Slider 3.x
Vinaora Nivo Slider 3.xVinaora Nivo Slider 3.x
Vinaora Nivo Slider 3.x
Vinaora Nivo Slider 3.x
Vinaora Nivo Slider 3.x
Vinaora Nivo Slider 3.x