Vinaora Nivo Slider 3.xVinaora Nivo Slider 3.xVinaora Nivo Slider 3.x
Vinaora Nivo Slider 3.xVinaora Nivo Slider 3.xVinaora Nivo Slider 3.x

Anguilla talks end without deal after Saint-Martin fishing boat stopped and catch seized.

Saint-Martin’s business chamber is pushing for immediate passage arrangements and written rules on fishing licenses as Anguilla prepares to consult its own fishermen.

saintmartinanguilla19112026MARIGOT, Saint-Martin:---  A Saint-Martin delegation returned from Anguilla on Wednesday, November 18, without an agreement after Anguillian authorities intercepted a Saint-Martin fishing vessel and seized its catch. Anguilla told the delegation its fishing regulations had not changed and that authorities had stepped up enforcement. Its government wants to hear from Anguillian fishermen before talks continue.

The seizure has brought a long-standing question to the forefront. Saint-Martin fishermen want clear rules for crossing Anguilla’s territorial waters to reach fishing grounds beyond the 12-nautical-mile limit. They also want answers on whether they can obtain licenses to fish in Anguillian waters and what documents officers will require during at-sea inspections.

The Chamber of Commerce of Saint-Martin, known as the CCISM, called on Thursday for an immediate interim arrangement under which Saint-Martin-registered vessels could declare their passage through Anguillian waters on their way to fishing grounds beyond the limit. The chamber also wants each side to name a contact who can be reached if a boat is stopped. The proposed arrangement would cover transit. Fishing inside Anguillian waters would remain subject to Anguilla’s authorization.

Fishermen seek written rules after years of informal exchanges

The talks followed a strike notice and mounting concern among Saint-Martin’s maritime professionals. CCISM President Angèle Dormoy met with representatives of the maritime professionals’ collective earlier in the week. The delegation that traveled to Anguilla included representatives of the Préfecture, the Collectivité, the CCISM and the port. They met with Anguilla’s premier and the minister responsible for maritime affairs.

Saint-Martin’s fishermen are asking to preserve longstanding practices, get a clear answer on fishing licenses and speak directly with Anguillian authorities. The chamber said relations between fishermen on the two islands have long relied on regular exchanges and good-neighbor practices. With tighter enforcement, it wants those operating conditions spelled out in writing.

Beyond passage, the chamber is proposing that the two sides explore a licensing system, agree on which documents must be kept aboard, and clarify how inspections will be conducted. It also wants tools to record where vessels fish and what they catch so authorities can verify that information during checks.

The chamber called for a joint working group with officials and fishermen from both islands and said a follow-up meeting was expected next week. It also wants the French state to support a lasting cooperation agreement. Any arrangement covering Anguilla’s territorial waters requires Anguillian authorities' agreement.

Chamber to document seized catches and lost fishing days

While the talks continue, the CCISM says it is setting up a dedicated fisheries desk to register affected vessels and operators and follow individual cases involving inspections or seizures. It is preparing a guide on the documents crews should carry and what to do if stopped in Anguillian waters. The chamber also plans to help operators with potential license applications, equipment to track fishing activity, and access to available funding, including through the European Maritime, Fisheries and Aquaculture Fund.

The chamber will compile a record of losses, including seized catches and days fishermen were unable to work, and submit it to the French state and the Collectivité. Commercial fishing supports Saint-Martin families and supplies local restaurants, shops and markets.

The CCISM urged maritime professionals to keep other businesses operating as discussions continue, saying blockades affecting sectors outside the dispute would impose costs on other workers and businesses. It credited Saint-Martin’s senator with helping open talks and acknowledged the participation of the Collectivité's president and the involvement of the préfet and his staff.

For Saint-Martin crews, the immediate question is whether Anguilla will agree to a declared passage procedure while licensing talks continue. Wednesday’s meeting ended with that proposal still on the table.


Anguilla says no fishing licenses granted after French delegation seeks about 12.

Saint-Martin fishermen who said they were left out of the first talks secured a separate meeting and opposed a blockade. Anguillian fishermen called for fair treatment on both sides.

kylehodge19112026THE VALLEY, Anguilla:--- Anguilla’s government says it has neither approved nor issued fishing licenses to French fishermen after a delegation from Saint-Martin and Saint-Barthélemy requested about 12 licenses to fish in Anguillian territorial waters. The November 18 talks ended without a licensing agreement, and Anguilla says it will continue consulting those whose livelihoods would be affected before making any decision on access.

The meeting, led by Anguilla Premier Cora Richardson-Hodge, followed the interception of a Saint-Martin fishing vessel and the seizure of its catch. Anguillian authorities told the French delegation that fishing regulations had stayed the same and that enforcement had intensified, according to Saint-Martin’s Chamber of Commerce, known as the CCISM.

Saint-Martin fishermen seek their own hearing

After the official talks, a group of Saint-Martin fishermen traveled independently to Anguilla and requested a meeting. The government agreed to hear them. The fishermen said they had not been represented in the earlier discussions and wanted Anguillian officials to hear directly about the regulatory difficulties they face and their concerns over who speaks for them.

The group also opposed the proposed blockade, warning that it would harm longstanding family, cultural and economic ties between the fishing communities. Anguillian fishermen joined that meeting and raised concerns about the proposal to license French pelagic fishermen. They said any future arrangement should address the difficulties Anguillian crews face on the French side and ensure fair treatment in both directions.

During the official talks, Anguilla’s Minister of Economic Development and Natural Resources, Kyle Hodge, relayed reports from Anguillian fishermen of damaged gear, destroyed catches, threats and restrictions affecting access to their own fishing grounds and to markets in Saint-Martin. The government said any access decision would have to protect local livelihoods and marine resources, uphold Anguillian law, and provide reciprocal treatment.

The chamber seeks immediate passage for boats headed beyond 12 nautical miles

The CCISM is pressing for an interim arrangement that would allow Saint-Martin-registered vessels to declare their transit through Anguillian waters on their way to fishing grounds beyond the 12-nautical-mile limit. It also wants each territory to designate a contact for crews stopped at sea. The transit proposal concerns passage through Anguillian waters. The request for about 12 licenses concerns fishing within those waters. Both remain unresolved.

The chamber is also seeking written rules on what documents crews must carry, how inspections should be conducted and how fishing locations and catches can be recorded. It says it is setting up a fisheries desk to track inspections and seizures, help operators with paperwork and document the value of seized catches and the number of fishing days lost for submission to the French state and the Collectivité.

A proposed joint committee would give officials and fishing representatives a forum to address disputes and recommend solutions. Anguilla said its role would be advisory and that its mandate would exclude granting or facilitating fishing licenses. The CCISM said a follow-up meeting was expected the following week.

Existing cruising permit rules remain in force

The November 18 meeting also addressed proposed amendments to Anguilla’s cruising permit rules. The changes would clarify where visiting vessels may operate, how passengers are cleared, what safety requirements apply and what penalties operators could face for violations. Anguilla said existing cruising permit requirements remain in force and reiterated that foreign vessels doing business in the territory must obtain the required documentation and comply with local law.

Richardson-Hodge reaffirmed Anguilla’s commitment to continued talks and to enforcing its laws in its territorial waters. For crews awaiting the next round, the immediate question is whether Anguilla will agree to a declared passage procedure while the request for fishing licenses is still under discussion.

Gumbs wants three garbage collection fees tied to building permits

patricegumbs19112026PHILIPSBURG:--- VROMI Minister Patrice Gumbs Jr. wants to introduce three garbage collection fees tied to building permits. The proposal raises an immediate question for homeowners and developers planning construction: what would they have to pay, and what collection service would each charge cover?

The available excerpt of Gumbs’ parliamentary presentation does not identify the three charges, their proposed rates, or when they would apply. It also remains unclear whether the fees would be one-time charges at the permit stage or recurring payments after a building opens.

Four major culverts damaged, one already condemned

In his briefing to Parliament, Gumbs said limited funding was the main obstacle to repairing public infrastructure that his ministry has known needs attention since last year. An island-wide inspection covered drains, trenches, roads, sidewalks, guardrails, traffic signs and mirrors.

Among the most serious findings was severe damage to all four major culverts on A.J.C. Brouwer Road. Gumbs said one had already been condemned, and the ministry was working to condemn and repair the other three. He also warned that continued erosion along the trench near Milton Peters College could eventually compromise the school’s foundations. In Fort Willem, two undersized drainpipes are scheduled for replacement next year, he said.

The minister also identified the need for more underground drainage capacity along Orange Grove Road as development in the Cole Bay Hill area has increased over the years. The ministry commissioned a new study this year to assess how to improve drainage from Union Road and Orange Grove Road toward the lagoon. The ministry also flagged flooding on Beacon Hill Road, drainage problems on Well Road, and erosion along several trenches.

VROMI weighs private financing and infrastructure mapping

Gumbs said the ministry is exploring public-private partnerships to help cover gaps in infrastructure funding. He cited Aruba’s use of private financing for roads as an example the ministry is examining. He did not announce that Sint Maarten would adopt that model.

The ministry is also discussing the cost of a joint mapping project with the Cadastre, with implementation now targeted for 2027. Gumbs said incomplete records of what lies beneath roads can delay repairs when crews make discoveries after excavation has begun. The proposed assessment would use drone and LiDAR data as part of a broader effort to map public infrastructure.

For anyone preparing a building permit application, the immediate issue is the cost of the proposed garbage collection charges. The three fee descriptions, the rates and the point at which each would become payable are still needed to determine how the proposal would affect a construction budget.

VROMI must release the records behind the 2026–2029 Garbage Collection Tender.

Public statement from the concerned garbage collection haulers

garbagehaulers19112026PHILIPSBURG:--- VROMI has told bidders which companies it selected for garbage collection parcels, yet the results it sent us leave 40 of the 100 evaluation points unexplained. We are calling on the Ministry to release the complete scoring, disclose what equipment and staffing it verified before making its selections, and suspend finalization and implementation until an independent reviewer examines the procurement file.

Minister Patrice Gumbs maintains that no contracts have been awarded. VROMI has already ranked bidders, identified its preferred contractors for specific parcels and communicated those results through Mercell. The public deserves to know how the Ministry reached those decisions and whether it applied the published rules equally to every bidder.

1. Release the notices and explain what VROMI decided

The scoring comparisons we received identified the winning bidder. We are also aware of a notice informing a selected bidder that a parcel had been awarded to that company. If the decision was provisional, VROMI should release the full notice and cite the tender provision that made it conditional.

The Ministry should publish a dated account showing when the rankings were approved, when bidders were notified, what conditions remained and whether any contracts have since been signed.

2. Show how two companies qualified to service two parcels each

The original tender limited each contractor to one parcel. The reopened tender allowed a contractor to receive two. Minister Gumbs defended the change, saying companies with sufficient equipment, personnel, and financial capacity could service more than one area. Limitless Construction and Leonard Enterprises were each identified for two parcels.

We understand that both companies approached former haulers about renting equipment after the selections were communicated. VROMI should release the dated evidence it relied on to determine that each company could service two parcels simultaneously. Which trucks and equipment were documented when bids were scored? What staffing did the committee verify? Which resources could be confirmed later?

VROMI should clarify whether it could still ask the highest-ranked bidders to demonstrate access to equipment and personnel before finalization. The Ministry should explain which commitments earned points, which requirements could be satisfied later, and whether every bidder had the same opportunity to provide additional evidence. If a selected bidder failed to meet a requirement, VROMI should show how it applied the tender’s reallocation provisions.

3. Account for all 100 points

Under the scoring framework communicated to bidders, 60 points covered documentation, presentation, methodology, and related criteria. The remaining 40 points covered price. The results you sent omitted the price scores. Without the formula, the points assigned and the combined totals, bidders cannot reproduce the rankings.

Based on the prices available to us, we selected the lowest-priced bids for Parcels 1, 3, and 6. We selected some of the highest-priced bids for other parcels. A higher-priced bid can win under a weighted evaluation. VROMI should publish the technical and price scores for every parcel so bidders can see precisely how those results were reached.

In one case, a selected hauler did not submit the lowest bid on any parcel. VROMI should disclose that hauler’s price score for every parcel it bid on and show how it calculated the scores against the lowest eligible offers.

4. Explain why a current hauler scored lower on experience

In the scoring records available to us, a company currently performing a garbage collection contract received 3 points for company relevance and experience. A selected bidder that, to our knowledge, had never held a garbage collection contract received 4.2 and 4.3 points under that criterion. We also question how a selected bidder whose access to equipment is disputed scored higher on equipment than a hauler already performing the service.

VROMI should identify the experience and equipment evidence it credited. If the committee counted comparable work, employees’ prior experience or commitments to supply equipment, it should identify the criteria it used and show how it scored equivalent evidence from other bidders.

5. Identify the evaluators and answer the questions raised on November 5

Our understanding of the tender documents is that participants were to be told who sat on the evaluation committee. We requested the official membership and still have no confirmed list. VROMI should identify who was appointed, who scored the bids, and who approved the rankings. An independent reviewer should have access to conflict-of-interest declarations, recusals, and records of any score changes.

At the November 5 meeting, Minister Gumbs indicated that bidders would receive more information. VROMI should clarify whether any bidders lost points because they attached incorrect documents to their submissions. The Ministry should identify the documents it evaluated, any deductions it made, and the rules governing those deductions. The independent reviewer should compare the original Mercell submissions and timestamps with the files actually scored and determine whether bidders had equal opportunities to clarify or supplement their submissions.

6. Open the canceled tender to independent review

Minister Gumbs said 11 of the 17 original submissions were eliminated for procedural deficiencies and the remaining six failed to meet the Terms of Reference. VROMI then reopened bidding for the same six parcels under revised conditions.

The Ministry should release the written reasons for the exclusions and cancellation, the decision approving the two-parcel rule, and records showing who had access to bid prices from the canceled round and when. An independent reviewer should determine whether bidders had access to that information on equal terms and whether the revised conditions gave any bidder an advantage.

Preserve the records and pause the tender

Five haulers raised these concerns in a joint complaint dated October 27. The Minister’s reference to objections from four bidders leaves unanswered how VROMI handled that joint complaint. We estimated in the complaint that more than 40 jobs could be affected.

Ahead of the court proceedings reported for November 27, we ask the court to intervene and order VROMI to preserve the complete procurement file and suspend finalization and implementation pending an independent review. That review must cover the full 100-point scoring, dated equipment and staffing evidence, committee appointments, original Mercell submissions, and all selection and award notices.

The missing price scores, differences in experience and equipment ratings, and questions about when selected bidders secured equipment raise serious concerns about possible preferential treatment. The independent review must establish whether any bidder received an advantage, whether that advantage was deliberate, and whether VROMI applied the published rules consistently. If the evidence points to possible criminal conduct, we will refer the relevant records to the Public Prosecutor’s Office for assessment.

Release the scores. Show what capacity was verified before selection. Identify who approved the rankings. VROMI should be able to answer those questions for every bidder and every parcel.

MP Doran challenges new building permit fee as Lewis and York press VROMI on spending and enforcement.

doranlewisyork19112026PHILIPSBURG:---   MP Egbert Jurendy Doran challenged VROMI Minister Patrice Gumbs Jr. in Parliament over a proposed development fund charge tied to building permits, asking why applicants should pay a second charge based on the estimated cost of construction. MP Lyndon Lewis called on government to collect outstanding fees and carry out projects already under discussion, while MP Darryl York asked whether homeowners, small businesses and major developers would face the same charges.

Doran questions a second charge based on construction value

Doran said the existing building permit fee is already based on a share of the estimated construction value. He said he could see a case for raising the separate processing fee from 200 to 300 guilders to account for rising costs. His objection was to adding another percentage-based charge on the same construction estimate to finance a development fund.

“How can you be charging me twice for the same service?” Doran asked. He pressed Gumbs to say who proposed the charge and explain why the ministry was pursuing it while government land fees remained outstanding. Doran said the government had dismantled a collection task force intended to pursue large businesses with unpaid balances and argued that those debts should be collected before residents face another charge.

Doran also pressed the minister on work in Sucker Garden. He said Gumbs had told Parliament during the budget debate that the project had no building permit, no plan and no signed agreement. Doran asked what oversight applied to the bridge work, who would be liable if it failed, and whether inspectors would apply the same rules to a resident who began construction near King of the Sea Road. He cited the scrutiny applied to the Westview project and asked how the ministry reconciled its handling of the two cases.

On road repairs, Doran asked how much capital funding VROMI had spent in 2026 and why pothole patching appeared to stop within days of starting. He also called for a lasting fix at a Cole Bay intersection where, he said, a missing one-way sign had left drivers unfamiliar with the area continuing straight into the restricted stretch.

Lewis calls for collection of outstanding fees and action on existing plans

Lewis backed Doran’s call to collect money already owed to government. He questioned why the ministry was considering an additional or higher charge while fees remained uncollected for years. He also said ordinary residents struggled to obtain permission for small jobs, citing a case involving a shed that he said he had raised with the minister and his chief of staff.

Lewis said the National Alliance faction had requested the infrastructure meeting a year earlier. He questioned what residents had gained from repeated presentations while complaints kept reaching MPs. He pointed to pothole patching that began around the budget debate and pressed Gumbs for work that residents could see completed.

“When are we going to start executing things in this country for the people?” Lewis asked.

York asks who would pay and how VROMI measures results

York asked whether the proposed charges under the Urban Environment Development Fund would distinguish between residential and commercial permits, and between small businesses and large developers. A homeowner making a modest addition and a developer building for profit, he argued, should be assessed in light of the different scale and purpose of their projects.

York also questioned consistency in enforcement. He described a resident who received a stop order for a small addition to her home, then pointed to a high-rise in Pelican that he said lacked the proper paperwork. York acknowledged that Gumbs said he had been unaware of the high-rise and asked how inspectors could detect a small addition while a much larger project went up. He also requested an update on outstanding permit documentation for the Setai development in Indigo Bay.

On infrastructure, York asked whether a new Cole Bay drainage study addressed his earlier concern that the proposed works stopped short of the lagoon, with homes still between the end of the project and the outlet. He asked what design standards VROMI uses for drainage, whether contractors receive drawings before work starts, and whether the ministry could combine existing utility maps from GEBE, TelEm and Flow into a government database. He also sought an update on replacing a condemned culvert in Cole Bay and asked what VROMI and the Ministry of Justice had done to improve recovery of insurance payments for damaged guardrails.

York welcomed the minister’s stated direction for a road fund focused on major infrastructure works, with routine maintenance remaining within the ministry. He said Gumbs had reached out to discuss how that proposal could work alongside an amendment York is preparing.


Subcategories

Vinaora Nivo Slider 3.x
Vinaora Nivo Slider 3.xVinaora Nivo Slider 3.x
Vinaora Nivo Slider 3.x
Vinaora Nivo Slider 3.x
Vinaora Nivo Slider 3.x
Vinaora Nivo Slider 3.x